Jimmy's Pizza

Discover Jimmy's Pizza in Mamaroneck, NY, offering signature slices, hearty meatball pies, and a cozy atmosphere. Enjoy homemade pies, sausage parm, gyros, and more with friendly service. Call +1 914-698-5804!

Welcome to Jimmy's Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Jimmy's Pizza
Jimmy's Pizza
Jimmy's Pizza
Jimmy's Pizza

Discover the warmth of Jimmy's Pizza, a beloved spot embedded in the heart of Mamaroneck, New York. Located at 822 Mamaroneck Ave, this charming pizza restaurant has become a local favorite for its signature slices and inviting atmosphere. Known for its homemade thick crust and thin crust options, it caters to diverse preferences and tastes. Customers rave about the meatball pie and sausage parm, but the true gem might just be the personal pizzas that deliver on flavor with every bite.

Whether you're stopping in for a quick meal or lounging with friends, Jimmy's Pizza creates an atmosphere where satisfaction meets community spirit. Their friendly owner greets everyone with a smile, enhancing the warm and cozy vibe that locals appreciate.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

822 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, United States

Phone

+1 914-698-5804

About

The Culinary Story

Jimmy's Pizza
Jimmy's Pizza
Jimmy's Pizza
Jimmy's Pizza

Jimmy's Pizza isn't just a restaurant; it's a community hub that blends tradition with genuine hospitality. Every pizza starts with high-quality ingredients that are carefully selected. Regular patrons often share stories of the first time they tried the meatball pie, many returning for that same comforting taste. The menu also embraces variety with both thick and thin crust styles, appealing to the adventurous eater as well as the tradition-seeker. Families find a welcoming spot here, where children enjoy digging into personal pizzas while parents savor a savory slice accompanied by a crisp salad.

The restaurant's ambiance, characterized by checked tablecloths and walls adorned with local memorabilia, encapsulates the charm of Mamaroneck. More than just meals, it serves moments—and memories. Engaging with the community goes beyond serving food. The owner often hosts local events and pizza-making nights, bringing everyone together for a fun and interactive experience. With a commitment to customer service, above all, Jimmy's Pizza stands out as a place that treasures both its dishes and its patrons.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday11 AM-9 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-10 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-10 PM

Jimmy's Pizza offers a delightfully compact menu that packs a punch. The highlight includes their signature slices, where each pie is crafted with a perfect balance of fresh ingredients and homemade sauce. Popular appetizers like Jimmy's Stix Basket provide a savory start to your meal, while the salads, including the zesty Taco Salad and fresh Dinner Salad, ensure a balance of taste and nutrition.

With an average dish price of just $3.33, affordability meets quality in every order. The restaurant maintains a cozy, family-friendly environment that makes it easy to gather around the table. Regulars often enjoy casual chats with the friendly owner, creating a welcoming community vibe. Open daily, this little pizzeria is perfect for lunch breaks, family dinners, or a midnight slice with friends.

Jimmy's Pizza

As you approach Jimmy's Pizza, the quaint exterior exudes an inviting warmth, complete with a classic New York charm. The subtle red and white marquee lights welcome you as they flicker playfully against the backdrop of the street. Outdoor seating allows diners to enjoy the hustle of Mamaroneck while indulging in their favorite pizza, making it a perfect spot for people-watching, especially during warmer months. The cozy outdoor vibe complements the interior's charm, ensuring that whether inside or out, patrons feel right at home. This is not just a pizza place; it’s a community landmark where the atmosphere enhances every dining experience.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Let me tell you something. I've been on this earth for 39 years and probably been driving by this place for at least 2/3 of them. Finally, tonight, I decided to just stop in. I met the son and daughter-in-law of the owner, They were two of the nicest people that I've met. Had a great conversation. I got four slices to go, and the pizza was excellent, I ate all four slices on the car ride home. I'm actually pissed at myself for not having stopped in sooner. Will definitely be back for more, and happy to add them to my pizza rotation. Solid pizza, solid people, 5 stars.

G
Gregory L.

Best pizza I've ever had. If you want some New York pizza this is the most genuine place to go. Wonderful customer service. Jimmy was extremely sweet. The pizza was so delicious and definitely a place worth going to. Highly recommend going to Jimmy's Pizza. Hopefully I will be able to go again in the future. Say hi to Jimmy.

A
Andrew M.

I went there for a quick lunch take out and the gentlemen working the counter was very friendly. The pizza was extra tasty and I noticed the crust was a bit thicker than typical which I liked. Also, the cheese tasted very high quality.

M
Maggie S.

Popped in this evening for some takeout and I am so impressed! The pizza has this incredible pillowy crust which somehow remains light - absolute perfection. And the wonderful owner, can't compliment him enough - I'll certainly be back again!

G
Grainne H.

Delicious slices. Stopped quickly on our way home from the airport. Jimmy and the woman working with him were both so friendly and we loved the cozy atmosphere. I'd love to come back and sit and talk with them over pizza. Affordably priced and great local vibes.

B
Brooke S.

Jimmy's , well I had never been there drove past it and just knew it had to have good pizza. I was right. I got a Large pie, had a nice conversation with an unofficial employee and was asked to see if the pie was to my liking for the first time. Cooked in a pan and then put into the oven for a nice crisp on the bottom. Delicious out of the box and great at home out of the toaster!!

P
Paul N.